Painful Reality of Being An 'Undocumented' American
Get real, America! Becoming a "legal" immigrant is NOT easy!
EXCERPT: As a fellow journalist and immigrant, I've always felt a connection to the issue of immigration and the plight of undocumented immigrants. I've spent a good part of my career reporting on these issues, and reading Vargas' article reminded me how truly uneducated the general population is in regards to immigration and how that needs to be changed for this conversation to move forward.
Read more in ¿Qué más?: Is the new STARS bill better than the DREAM Act?
When I first realized this, I couldn't believe the amount of people that are so uninformed/misinformed about how the immigration system actually works in this country. I mean, it's obviously not a requirement for anyone to know this information, but if you're going to have an opinion about the issue, you should at least get informed. Unfortunately, the mainstream media--where most people go to find information--is hugely responsible for perpetuating the unfounded myths that abound regarding immigration.
One of the most common misconceptions is that the process of becoming a documented or "legal" immigrant is simple and everyone should just follow the rules, get in line and get a green card. My reaction to that one is always the same: if it's so easy, why wouldn't every single undocumented immigrant do just that? Do people seriously think undocumented immigrants like living in the shadows? Living in fear of being discovered and getting deported from the only country they've ever really known?
My Two Cents Worth: I can't help but envision the worlds human population as one. I know people are very territorial, just like the other animal species, and I suppose its an important part of the evolution and perpetuate the species process to feel these innate gut-responses of THATS MINE NOT YOURS. Life forms must protect their territories in order to have a somewhat safe haven to bring forth new generations. I saw this in action the other night; the many birds that live in trees on my property let out a certain shrill, come sundown. When I heard their screeching sounds I knew there was danger in the vicinity for these feathered creatures. Sure enough, there was a huge owl lurking in the tree camouflaged and looking like a part of it. The screeching got louder and soon the owl spread his mighty wings and landed on the ground with small birds dive bombing it. The owl was out to dine on, no doubt, one of the adult birds fledglings and he wasnt about to leave the scene hungry. The smaller birds were very upset with this intruder but could do nothing about it but alert each other to the impending peril.
When it comes to humans, the so called territorial space is a whole country, and for some their actions are very similar to the birds. They feel as though this real estate cut from the Earths land masses, where they were born, belongs to only them and no one else should intrude upon their soil.
I realize there has to be laws protecting ones space but the immigration laws the Republicans are trying to shove down our throats are barbaric and without thought. They are based upon peoples unfounded fears but what else is new? The Republicans are masters at using fear to get what they want. Fear is easy.
I just came across another thought provoking article written by Fareed Zakaria a good read that will give you the facts on what is happening in our country regarding immigration and it is nothing to be proud of. America, thanks to the right-wing is fast becoming a cruel place and a Second-Rate Nation. Those of us who are not influenced by the fear mongers must try to put a stop to this downward decline of our image and America itself. Its win at all cost for for the GOP, they have proved this time and again. The sad thing is, that it appears they are unstoppable, they have got the momentum; they have a land full of ignorant people who refuse to read and research the many misleading facts that are spoon-feed to them by the callous leaders of their party, who feel no shame. thinkingblue
Broken and Obsolete
Posted by Fareed Zakaria on June 8, 2012 · Leave a Comment
An immigration deadlock makes the U.S. a second-rate nation
By Fareed Zakaria
As the American economy sags, the race for the presidency gets tighterexcept in one dimension. Hispanic Americans continue to support Barack Obama by an astonishing 61%-to-27% margin. Were Obama to win, it might well be because of his attitudes on one issue: immigration. But it is an issue on which he will be unable to enact any of his preferences, let alone those policies that many Latinos support. The Republican Party has taken a tough stand on the topic. Democrats have their own bright lines. That means Americas immigration system is likely to stay as it is right nowutterly broken.
We think of ourselves as the worlds great immigrant society, and of course, for most of the countrys history, that has been true. But something fascinating has happened over the past two decades. Other countries have been transforming themselves into immigrant societies, adopting many of Americas best ideas and even improving on them. The result: the U.S. is not as exceptional as it once was, and its immigration advantage is lessening.
Would you have guessed that Canada and Australia both have a higher percentage of foreign-born residents than the U.S.? In fact, in this respect, Americawhich once led the worldincreasingly looks like many other Western countries. France, Germany and the U.K. have only slightly fewer foreign-born residents than America (as a percentage of the population). And some of these countries have managed to take in immigrants mostly based on their skills, giving a big boost to their economies.
Canadian immigration policy is now centered on recruiting talented immigrants with abilities the country needs. Those individuals can apply for work visas themselves; they dont even need to have an employer. The Canadian government awards points toward the visa, with extra points for science education, technical skills and work experience.
The results of the system are evident in Vancouver, where American high-technology companies like Microsoft has large research laboratories and offices. The people working in these offices are almost all foreign graduates of American universities who could not get work visas in the U.S. They moved a few hours north to Vancouver, where they live in a city much like those on the American West Coast. Except, of course, that they will pay taxes, file patents, make inventions and hire people in Canada.
Sixty-two percent of permanent-resident visas in Canada are based on skills, while the remainder are for family unification. In the U.S., the situation is almost exactly the reverse: two-thirds of Americas immigrants enter through family unification, while only 13% of green cards are granted because of talent, merit and work. And its actually gotten worse over time. The cap on applications for H1-B visas (for highly skilled immigrants) has dropped in half over the past decade.
Its not as if America doesnt need these people. American companies are struggling to fill 3.7 million job openings, many of them in science-related fields. Meanwhile, foreign students receive half of all doctorates in such fields, and almost all of them will head home after graduation. (In recent years, the H1-B visa limit was reached within the first few days of filing!) New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg calls Americas immigration policy the single biggest problem facing the economy and argues that our current approach is national suicide.
It isnt just Canada to which America is losing the best and brightest. Australia, Britain and Singapore are all wooing the worlds most talented graduates. And then there are China and India, where many of these graduates come from. As those countries develop economically, new opportunities grow there, and lots of Indians and Chinese decide to go back home. The Beijing government makes a serious effort to recruit many of these people, from recent college graduates to tenured professors at the worlds best universities. The evidence is that increasingly it is succeeding.
But none of these broad arguments to reform Americas immigration system will make much difference while the partisan standoff remains. Those who have hard-line views on this topic believe that immigration reform must start with taking control of the border through more stringent patrols, more effective fences and wider deportations like those that have been under way for years.
While the ideological battles over immigration persist, something strange has happened on the ground: Mexican immigration to America is slowing to a standstill. The Pew Hispanic Center released a report in April showing that net Mexican migration into the U.S.those entering minus those going back to Mexicois now zero and that the number of Mexicans going back might actually now be higher than the number entering. This trend might be partly a product of tougher enforcement, but it is most likely caused by economic weakness in the U.S. coupled with a striking decline in Mexican fertility rates (which is itself caused by more education and opportunities in Mexico).
Whether or not this trend holds, the U.S. has to deal with the workers who are already here. The most sensible solution would be to craft legislation that would deport those who have criminal records and give some kind of legal status to the others. The path to citizenship for these workers should properly be long, placing them behind regular applicants and visa holders, and could take 15 years, during which they would have to pay all their taxes and abide by all laws.
That would allow a real reform of the system. We should sharply reduce the number of legal immigrants who arrive because they are sponsored by a family member. We should expand massively the number who come in because they have skills we need. We should recognize that certain industries do need temporary workersfarms in California, for exampleand those industries could set up temporary-worker programs so crops can get picked during harvesting season. Ideally, such a bill would be bipartisan, sponsored by a prominent Democrat and an equally prominent Republican. Naturally, it should have the strong support of the President.
The tragedy, of course, is that we had such a bill. It was sponsored in 2005 by Senators John McCain and Ted Kennedy and strongly supported by then President George W. Bush. It did not even get to the floor of the Senate or House for a vote. The right hated it because it provided a legal path for undocumented workers, the left because it reduced family unification. And the unions opposed the temporary-worker provisions.
In an earlier era, the fact that the more extreme wings of the parties disliked the bill might actually have made passage easier, because that meant it was supported at the center, where the action lay. Today all the power has shifted to the wings of the two parties, who control their agendas. The failure of immigration reform is a metaphor for the breakdown of the political process. The simple fact is that in a country of more than 300 million people, any policy is going to have opponentsnot everyone agrees with youbut the opponents can now paralyze the process. So nothing gets done.
Its a sad state, because the U.S. remains a model for the world. It is the global melting pot, the place where a universal nation is being created. We may not do immigration better than everyone else anymore, but we do assimilation better than anyone else. People from all over the world come to this country and, almost magically, become Americans.
TheyI should say wecome to the country with drive and dedication and over time develop a fierce love for America. This infusion of talent, hard work and patriotism has kept the country vital for the past two centuries. And if we can renew it, it will keep America vital in the 21st century as well.
In a world proud of the prosperity and profundity that a global village creates, it seems odd that there is so much discrimination and resentment. Might we, as a larger community, realize that times have changed, technology has altered our reality? Nationally, or internationally, we are all connected.
'national socialists') look at the supposedly secret deals that
run the world 'behind the scenes'. Child's play. Except that
childishness is sinister in adults.
~ Christopher Hitchens ~
PS: I changed the title from "We Are Americans - Just Not Legally" to "The Painful Reality of Being An 'Undocumented' American" because it characterizes what I am trying to express about a situation here in America THAT SHOULD NOT BE. thinkingblue
THE SADNESS CONTINUES:
Undocumented teen suicide Consequences of the failed DREAM Act vote in December 2010
by Dee Dee Garcia Blase on Nov. 27, 2011,
Failed DREAM Act Vote Rears Its Ugly Head
By DeeDee Garcia Blase
Co-President of the National Tequila Party Movement
May the death of Joaquin Luna not go in vain.
DREAM Act student, Joaquin Luna, recently took his life in Texas. At 18 years old, he had aspirations of becoming an engineer. He was one of ours. He
took his life because he felt as an undocumented immigrant he had nowhere to go. He relied and was hoping for the passage of the DREAM Act in December 2010 that could have been passed with only a handful more Senate votes. I knew there would be dire consequences to the failure of the December 2010 DREAM Act vote, but it is getting tougher and tougher to swallow news like this when we hear of children who feel they have no other option. Its heart wrenching. Just think, if the DREAM Act would have passed last December, we would not have to witness this precious life go to waste, and Im told Joaquin is not the first. MORE HERE